A critical review of the epidemiological evidence on foetal alcohol syndrome in south africa


Foetal Alcohol problem (FAS) describes "development, psychological and actual issues that might happen in an infant whenever a mom drinks booze during pregnancy" (Medline 2010). It's in the serious end-of the spectral range of Foetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder (FASD), in the different end-of the range is booze-associated neurodevelopmental disorder and alcohol related birth disorders (CDC 2003).FAS is among the top reasons for preventable birth defects and developmental problems (CDC 2003).

The united states Start of Medication analytical requirements for TREND is i) routine of facial flaws, (as observed in number below), two) decreased development for era iii) proof of central nervous anomalies like developmental setbacks and iv) established background of maternal alcohol intake (Sampson, Streissguth, Bookstein et al. 1997)

(Medline 2006)

the entire projected occurrence of FAS is 0.97 per 1000 live births (Godel H. 2002). Review of birth records in Victoria, Sydney from 1995-2001 where FAS is just a notifiable illness offered an occurrence of 0.014/1000 live births (Allen, Riley and Halliday 2007). Frequency of FAS within the Usa is believed to become 0.5-2.0/1000 live births (Might and Gossage 2001). Petcovic last year by which energetic situation monitoring was performed in quality 1-4 metropolitan schoolchildren performed in France research. Frequency of FAS was discovered to become 6.44/1000, PFAS 34.33/1000 and general frequency of FAS/PFAS 40.77/1000.Active event ascertainment technique in a primary-school in France offered the frequency of FAS as 3.7 - 7.4/1000children and FASD as 20.3-40.5 per 1000 (Might, Fiorentino, Gossage ETAL. 2006).


Searches were completed utilizing the key phrases: South Africa, alcohol-related birth defects, occurrence, frequency, epidemiology alcohol defects and foetal alcohol problem. Thirty-one posts were recognized. One more research was performed through internet of medline and understanding but no posts were acquired. Endeavor was designed to get the entire texts for deeper analysis and fifteen posts were regarded pretty related, two couldn't be gathered.

Addition and exemption criteria were created and used-to slim completed the research

Introduction criteria:

* Obviously identified cases of Foetal alcohol problem or Incomplete Foetal Alcohol Problem

* Reports performed after 1973

* Reports completed in Southafrica

* Reports performed on people

Exemption criteria:

* Reports that didn't clearly determine FAS or PFAS

* Reports performed before 1973

* Reports that utilizing extra information

* Reviews which were editorials

* Reports that complete statement couldn't be acquired

* Reports that elucidated treatment for FAS or PFAS

* Reports not completed in Southafrica

* Reviews which were not in Language





Foetal Alcohol Problem, Alcohol-Related Birth Defects, Foetal Alcohol Flaws



#1 + Epidemiology, frequency, occurrence



#2 + Southafrica



Eight case-control studies were identified. All-but among the reports was centered on Southafrica, the latter compared women with FAS identified kids and information between Plains ladies. Six reports were performed in the Cape Cod region on the cohort of quality 1 student in major schools. Information evaluation for these six studies' technique was lively case ascertainment. Two-rate testing was performed with a group of two: a doctor along with a dysmorphologist. Next, analysis of alcohol syndrome, delayed or not foetal alcohol problem was created. Three of the reports included two reports concentrated just about the moms and the kids. The final case-control research was a center based research that recognized their moms as well as kids damaged at clinics that are routine.

Overview of reports

S. No




Research design



Epidemiology of Fetal Alcohol Problem in a Southafrican neighborhood within the Western Cape Land

Gossageet al, may, Brooke. (2000)



39.2 - 42.9 per 1000


FAS epidemiology in a Southafrican (S/A) neighborhood: another research of the high frequency are

Viljoen, Gossage, Brooke. (2005)



65.2-74.2 per 1000


Booze usage along with other maternal risk factors for fetal alcohol problem among three unique examples of ladies, before during and after maternity: the chance is comparable

May White-Nation ETAL. (2004)



FAS relates to natural and ecological elements


Maternal risk factors for FAS within the western cape land of S/A: a population-based research

May, Gossage, Brooke. (2005)



Risk factors for FAS


The epidemiology of FAS and incomplete FAS in As/a residential area

May, Gossage, Marais. (2007)



68.0 - 89.2 per 1000


Maternal risk factors for FAS and incomplete FAS in S/A: a next research

May, Gossage, Marais. (2008)



Risk factors to FAS


Booze dehydrogense-2*2 allele is related to reduced frequency of FAS within the combined ancestry population of the Developed cape land, S/A

Viljoen, Carr et al. (2001)



ADH*2 allele is protecting against FAS


Three reports May ETAL. 2000, Viljoen. 2005. 2007 offered 1 kids in the decades the reports were performed to the frequency of FAS in quality. An incident control research was performed out of this cohort team (nested case-control). These reports had the next benefits: temporary connection could be determined, the reports are cheaper and less time is allocated to data-collection and evaluation when compared with a cohort study (Ernster 1994). There is growing frequency mentioned as time passes 39.2 - 42.9/1000, 65.2 - 74.2 / 1000 - 89.2/ 1000. This may be because of enhanced analytical abilities as time passes or the region is known by even the studies better. The very first research determined the frequency of FAS as the next and next determined incomplete FAS and both FAS. These reports also mentioned that kids with FAS were smaller, weighed had occipital- circumference and dysmorphic ratings that were greater compared to handles.

The three afore-mentioned studies, along with two studies. 2005. 2008 offered the chance factors for this problem. In most five reports, moms of instances were more prone to be present consumers who consumed and used and existed in rural places cigarettes during listing pregnancy. The kids with FAS's dads were present consumers. May ETAL. 2008. 2005 had large gravidity, didn't hope frequently and noted that parents of instances were solitary, not frequent churchgoers. There have been also more prone to be plantation workers, or unemployed if used.

Effective monitoring was employed within the reports mentioned for data-collection. This method's benefit is the fact that professionals wanted these kids out to help make the analysis, more instances is likely to be found while heading out to look locally for them than for them to provide within the health services by waiting. This provides a far more correct approach to calculating frequency (Might and Gossage 2001). This method's drawbacks contain it being costly for professionals need to be educated. It's also time intensive and wants the assistance of the large amount of people locally to be always a success (Might and Gossage 2001).

May 2004 ETAL. Compared information from South African and from acquired from Plains women girls. Data-collection was by center and effective monitoring based reports. It had been unearthed that with lower degrees of risk factors, South African females because of their lower-body mass list (BMI) and worse nutritional status had higher-risk of getting kids with FAS. Higher age of instances when compared with handles that was significant was observed. Exactly the same outcome (greater maternal age in instances) was acquired in May ETAL 2008. In May ETAL 2008, though moms with FAS's era identified kids was greater, it had been statistically insignificant.

Additional benefits obtained from May ETAL. 2001 were in reports that are concordance using the additional five previously mentioned. Moms of FAS kids were binge users of low-socioeconomic standing with large equality, coping with someone who drinks and solitary.

Viljoen. 2001 discovered that allele was lower within the cases and completed genotyping for kids with their moms, FAS and controls. This implies the allele is just a defensive element against growth of FAS. This finding is by Difficult 2003 in contract having a research.

Talents of reports

All of the instances except Viljoen. Collection methods had been described by 2001 for handles and instances. Medication analytical criteria's united states start was employed. In Viljoen. It wasn't established the control team was free of the condition. Body individuals that were previously gathered from contributors were utilized. The doctors were blinded throughout the event ascertainment to prevent observer error. Maternal alcohol intake during pregnancy, the publicity was determined in most instances. Handles and instances were acquired in the population. Exactly the same addition handles and and exemption criteria put on both instances. Related of instances to handles was completed in May ETAL. 2002 to lessen confounding's result. Surveys given to parents given in Africaans and were tailored to South Africa. The testing outcomes for that FAS weren't recognized to the moms before the surveys stuffed. It was to prevent writer opinion. Info from moms that may not be attained was acquired through collaterals. May ETAL. 2005, May. 2007. 2008 offered a-7 evening beverage record for that moms to load to prevent underreporting of existing drinking position. The research style utilized enables numerous exposures to become decided. Trying the whole neighborhood, collection bias removed. Being case-control reports, there is not a problem of reduction to check out up.


Moms were requested to remember activities encompassing therefore remember opinion CAn't be eliminated catalog maternity which happened eight decades beforehand. Some moms didn't provide permission for their kids to do this that might result in sample error and declined to be a part of the reports.

Drinking often happens in-groups and locally made liquor is usually eaten. It'll consequently not be easy to evaluate the precise quantity of alcohol taken. The binge drinking used by these ladies can result in memory loss. Additionally how they answer the surveys might be affected by the reduced degree of training predominant within the person population. Each one of these can result in reporting prejudice that'll influence the study's credibility.

May ETAL. The research was performed by 2005 having a sample-size of 169, no energy formula was documented. It'll not be possible when the sample-size is big enough to express. The accuracy of the research influences. In May ETAL. 2004. Confidence period wasn't mentioned although 2005 odds ratio was handed.

No analysis was completed in virtually any of the reports to regulate for confounders. The outcomes received consequently might have been consequently of confounders. Coordinating was just completed May ETAL 2002, in one single review.

the same of individuals performed each one of these reports. Viljoen was in most but among the reports in Could and all the studies. This review is consequently currently taking a look at info in the people is perspective which could result in prejudice.


The Western Cape Cod of South Africa is mentioned to truly have FAS's greatest frequency . These reports critiqued defined exactly the same elements present in studies performed elsewhere. These risk factors contain individual moms coping with a drinking companion, low-socioeconomic course, residing in rural places, large equality, not spiritual. Moms were present consumers who consumed through pregnancy. BMI of those ladies and poor people nutritional status likewise make sure they are predisposed to using kids with this specific situation. Booze dehydrogenese-2*2 allele was discovered to become defensive for FAS.

They absolutely increase our prosperity of understanding of this preventable situation although these reports aren't without defects. The emphasis should be on training their drinking practices to alter particularly while pregnant in order to have infants that are healthy.


1. K., Allen M. J, and Halliday. (2007) Calculating the frequency of FAS in Victoria utilizing regularly collected information. Aust N-Z N Public Health31(1): pp62-66

2. Middle for Disease Control (2003) Fetal alcohol problem--Alaska, Illinois, Co, and Ny, 1995-1997.MMWR:morbidity and death regular statement 51(20);433-5

3. Ernster. M. (1994) Stacked case-control reports. Preventive medicine 23: pp587-590

4. Godel, T. (2002) Foetal Alcohol Syndrome. Paediatr Child Health 7(3): pp161-174

5. Difficult, L.M. (2003) Alcohol dehydrogenase genotype, maternal alcohol use, and toddler result - where are we today? T FAS Int 1:e5

6. N, P. L., Croxford Adnams Robinson and Viljoen, may. (2000)Epidemiology of fetal alcohol problem in a Southafrican neighborhood within the Western Cape Province. Am J Public Health 90(12): pp1905-1912.

7. Might, P., Gossage, J., Brooke, Snell, C., M. A., Marais, Hendricks, L. J. D, and Viljoen. (2005) Maternal Risk Factors for Fetal Alcohol Problem within the Western Cape Province of South Africa: A Populace-Based Research. Am J Public Health 95(7): pp1190-1199.

8. Might, P., Gossage, J., Marais, A., Adnams, C., Hoyme, H., Jackson, E. M, Robinson. N., Khaloe, Snell Kalberg, W. L. L. D. D, and Viljoen. (2007) The epidemiology of fetal alcohol problem and incomplete FAS in a South African group. Alcohol and Medicine Dependence. 88(2-3): pp 259-271.

9. May, P.A. and Gossage, J.P. (2001) Calculating the frequency of foetal alcohol problem: an overview. Alcohol Research and Wellness 25(3): pp551

10. Might, P.A., Fiorentino, D., Gossage, J.P., Kalberg, W.O., Hoyme, H. Robinson, e., L.K. G. K.L. M., Tarani Romeo Kodituwakku Deiana Buckley, N. M, and Ceccanti. (2006) Epidemiology of FASD in a Land in France: Frequency and Faculties of Kids in a Random Test of Colleges. Alcohol Clin Exp Res thirty(9): pp 1562-1575

11. P.A., may, Gossage Marais, A. L. C. B.G. C., Stellavato D. M, Brooke. N, and Viljoen. (2008) Maternal Risk Factors for Fetal Alcohol Problem and Incomplete Fetal Alcohol Problem in Southafrica: A Next Research. Alcoholism: Medical & Fresh Study 32(5): pp738-753.

12. Might, P.A., Gossage, P., White-Nation, M., Goodhart, K., Decoteau, S., Trujillo, P., Kalberg W., Viljoen, N. E, and Hoyme. (2004) Alcohol usage along with other maternal risk factors for fetal alcohol problem among three unique examples of ladies before, during, and after maternity: the chance is comparable. American Journal of Medical Genetics Component C: Workshops in Medical Genetics 127C(1): pp10-20.

13. Medline (2006) Foetal Alcohol Problem [online]. Accessible at: http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/ency/imagepages/19842.htm [accessed 17/2/10]

14. Medline (2010) Foetal Alcohol Problem [online]. Offered at http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/ency/article/000911.htm [accessed 18/2/10]

15. Nayak, R. And Murthy P. (2008) Fetal alcohol spectrum disorder. Indian Pediatr. 45(12): pp977-983.

16. Petcovic, G. I, and Barisic. (2009) FAS frequency in an example of downtown schoolchildren in France. Reprod Toxicol. [Epub before printing]

17. Y, Sampson Streissguth Bookstein. Small, L., R.E. S.T. P. J.W. and Graham, J.M., (1997) Occurrence of Fetal Alcohol Problem and frequency of neurodevelopmental disorder Teratology 56: pp317-326

18. City, M., Chersich, M., Fourie, L., Chetty, C., Olivier, M. and Viljoen, D.(2008) Fetal alcohol problem among quality 1 schoolchildren in Northern Cape Province: frequency and risk factors. S Afr Med J. (11): pp877-82.

19. Viljoen, D.L., Carr, L.G., Forood, T.M., Brooke L., Ramsay M. T.K, and Li. (2001) Alcohol Dehydrogenase-2*2 Allele is Related To Reduced Frequency of Fetal Alcohol Problem within the Combined-Ancestry Populace of the Western Cape Domain, South Africa. Alcoholism: Fresh and Medical Research. 25(12): g. 1719-1722.

20. Viljoen, D.L., Gossage, J.P., Brooke, L., Adnams, C.M., Johnson, K.L., Robinson, L.K., Hoyme, H.E., Snell, C., Khaole, N.C., Kodituwakku, P., Asante, K.O., Findlay, R., Quinton, B., Marais, A.S., Kalberg, W.O. And Could P.A (2005) Fetal Alcohol Syndrome Epidemiology in a Southafrican Group: Another Research of the High Frequency Region. T Stud Alcohol 66(5): pp593-604.

21. Warren, K., Calhoun, F., Might, P., Viljoen, D., Li, T., Tanaka, H., Marinicheva, G.S., Robinson, L.K., Mundle, G., (2001) Fetal Alcohol Syndrome: A Global Perspective Alcoholism. Medical and Fresh Research25(5):pp 202S-206S