Materialism and idealism

Particularized on Analyzing the Informative and Propagandistic Worth of Two Views: “Idealism” and “Materialism”

Below I'll blend the concept of sociology of plan and the manner of qualitative information evaluation. I really hope that I'll be accepted in my own work to provide a mix of analytic capabilities particular to 1 research issue using another matter's observations - a little of horizontal thinking I believe it's pleasant within the college. A prior edition of the document was offered to prof. C.J.M. Schuyt.


For materialism: gold leg, common Mammon, kid-eating beast, red cows, Kingdom of Evil, exploiters, despisers of tradition, etc., etc.

For idealism: desires, composition, doesn't depend as technology, garbage, Nazism, communism, oppression, sexually frustrated people, combined processes, hate mongering, disaster prophets, anti-generous, anti-democratic, etc.

We're not worried below with such facts about cultural truth, but we're with what we might clinically show as correct technology concerned. E.g., the functional description of what's actual goes to Gustave Le Bon: “La véritable réalité des choses, c'est l'idée qu'on s'en fait”, this really is: “The really truth of issues may be the concept we've thereof”, my very own interpretation, based on Denis Touret's estimate. This notion was more produced by W.I.Thomas' opinion: as actual have actual results “things” defined.

Materialism in Technology

Financial sciences, so long as they calculate moves of customer and cash fulfillment, they're surrounded by their equipment that was argumentative to beg for that many really materialism creating fresh types and when it comes to valuable effectiveness of usage.

This statistical equipment is learned from the few ideas of the concept and also Adam Smithis to operationalize a concept which found your brain of Walras, them. Bourdieu appears to state that Walras is a few type of hearth- an utopian imagine global consumerism, which may guarantee peace and wealth for several along with spitting beast which attempts to matter everything all symptoms of cultural reality.

Personally, I consider that Walras was an excellent guy, having a good and required factor towards the sciences, but that his fans all too-actually got his techniques and assumptions, merely implementing them inside their narrowest range, in the place of trying to operationalize other forms of expenses than these materially-affordable. I believe there's an economy of intellect, an economy of the appealing degree of regulation and purchase, an economy of international policy, and hereby economy I am talking about evaluating the “costs” and “revenues” because of some steps which people and collectivities find to business them (e.g. a revolution may politically charge significantly more than easy lack of cash and/or lack of material issues).

Obviously, there's the now-famous amazing brain of John Nash, and also the thoughts of numerous others, who confirmed that affordable calculus isn't within the single possession of the economics of the content issues, however they wanted methods for rationalizing decision-making as well as global methods, as in prof. Abram de Swaanis instance with ANGRY (Mutually Assured Destruction), that was based on game concept.

Recognition is rendered by them towards economics' area, as well as their strategy is worth being followed not their bravery to operationalize what's never been operationalized, but although in a interpretation.

By evaluating the answers that they give a related current trend I'll attempt to enjoy the worthiness of the paradigm and of the paradigm, specifically the emotions of the findings all, and also uncertainty of the populace of them appear to provide. I am aware that's a reductionistic approach, for there are several idealisms in the place of one idealism, and lots of materialisms in the place of one materialism. But I really hope that reductionistic assessment of the value of two paradigms will not be drawn in its narrowness that is literalistic, however it is likely to be more created like a way of measuring the caliber of rational statements to complete the reality. It's, obviously, not The Reality, and merely a truth, but we might nevertheless state that you will find facts and lies, technology versus views.

While Marx stated “religion is opium for that people”, he was idealistic, not materialistic, as described thus, for he didn't evaluate affordable effectiveness of spiritual followership (which Weber did, through contemplating some imponderables), but he was providing a sophisticated philosophical take on his idea of philosophy.

Our stomach feeling appears to show that, even though it might be that one of those two monistic views of technology may be the accurate one, till our understanding will end up total and complete, we are compelled to depend on type of Lukacsian dualism, which combines both views in its asymptotical find of the greatest volume of facts offered at certain time. Which means that idealistic and materialistic examines will need to coexist eachother using the elements which the match of one ignores them.

For instance, it'd be excellent the cafeterias of the UvA be provided and coated with platinum bullion, and we might nevertheless permit bad individuals to get aid due to their adversities by eliminating and oz of this sidewalk, however this really is totally unlikely according towards the content expenses that are to become involved with introducing the cafeterias with bullion. For instance, UvA's budget would be surpassed by just the protection had a need to guard that location from the influx of vandalism for. Therefore, the content expenses provide a sign of what's impossible to be achieved in a second, in confirmed location and what's feasible.

And, the viewpoint is in knowing why, though some nations possess the assets to ease starvation nowadays; it's not going to merely have completed essential, since their beliefs don't permit that getting to occur. To a lot of countless hungry people, US wont compromise its budget for instance, be it for that cause that it'd eliminate hence its defensive capabilities, that will be prohibited by its beliefs.

A negative laugh I continue reading Web claims: What might occur it the Palestinians put their hands down? Peace. What might occur when the Israelis put their guns down? There could be no further Israel. This story's moral is actually irregular, hence the American ideal of universalism generally does not fulfill. But, it nonetheless claims a reality: that until some strange world eliminates all of the guns in the Planet in the same period, people may proceed to destroy one another, for there's no scarcity of factors to destroy somebody, but merely a scarcity of humaneness to avoid it. This really is obviously a mathematical take on the specific human character that is jointly aggregated. But, because facts are useful to people who believe, we might state that it's not negative but a laugh that is phlegmatic; phlegmatism is hence method a hide of cynicism used to be able to further the great.

Means of Existing Qualitative Research

Enough being stated on philosophical concerns, and we might change towards the ways of doing such research:

Qualitative data evaluation upon the (evidently) many related files according to public-policy, specifically King's Messages (that are compiled by the federal government, using the exclusion of her Holiday Talk).

Though I don't have confidence in the worthiness independence of technology, I love the type of Machiavelli, who makes scientific realities upon their state of details, supplying these looking forward to political observations to modify their government based on a scheme of accessible efficient methods of control and control. What prof is merely noted by me. He's just a political researcher who conducted an empirical evaluation of some issues of statesmanship, although DumitruLepadatu seen in College of Bucharest that Machiavelli isn't any guru of evil. If he came into existence described as a result a beast it's since (i) the people hate facts and (ii) facts aren't just ideal for some, however they can create substantial harm to others (particularly towards the ignorant).

This alethophobia is just a view of reality regarding scientific technology (that's, it's a well known fact that human-nature includes a tendency towards rest, also it relates to equally metaphysical theology and its own operationalization inside large therapy, based on GustaveLeBonis explanation of combined conduct), and this type of medical explanation continues to be empirically confirmed with several events.

On the basis of the accessibility on Web, I picked some current files: King's Messages (Throne Messages 1999-2004 + Holiday Talk of 2001) and Government Conditions (1998, 2002 and 2003).

I examined these texts when required using hermeneutics. The next qualitative fuzzy code was used:

Issue: idealism and analyzing the worthiness of two views: materialism, according to public discussion. I'll evaluate as designed to affect the general public view how both of these views are utilized.

Therefore, the concept of the evaluation is public response, as visible to be obtained in adjusting these files. Its objective is analyzing materialism within their interaction. Issue is: which stage keeps: Dutch government discovers that in its handle towards the people (i) materialism is much more valuable than idealism (ii) idealism is much more valuable than materialism (iii) both are useful, or, atleast none may skip therein.

Determination thereof is my philosophical curiosity: materialistic affordable evaluation is just a pretty effective and developed argumentative device, because it is extremely formalized mathematically, it uses the essences of large sums of information, also it CAn't be thus quickly bashed by person who isn't of enough training; we imply that, generally, reasons based on this Walrasian style of argumentation refer to “materialism”, i.e. steps of client study is just a way of measuring fulfillment having a given product, and view forms are steps of people' pleasure having a governmental product. Therefore “materialism” indicates the quantitative evaluation of its own following meaning in this brain body and the very really visible information.

By “idealism” I am talking about a choice for thinking reasons that were sophisticated, ideals, apparent and ethical choices, stated governmental pursuits, which are quickly nondeductible by quantitative- analyzing some circulation of vote programs or cash, customer comments.

Therefore, materialism and idealism thus resemble the difference between quantitative and qualitative evaluation, although not totally - for instance a quantitative analysis of imponderable ideals (when there is this type of “thing” as metaphysical data) is handled as idealistic along with a philosophical analysis of quickly-visible moves of products, cash, people, etc., it relates to the exact same meaning of idealism.

The functional description of idealism and materialism (inside technology and public discussion) is offered within the subsequent variance desk:

Character of evaluation









(They're great sorts, in the place of unique and positively obvious methods for producing difference. The phrase “pondering the imponderables” in not unusual, see

As an example the phrase “liberal democracy is the greatest regime” relates to imponderabilia, while checking oranges is definitely an instance of components that are most ponderable, and evaluating oranges is definitely an instance of material that is ponderable. In this way, rates according to empirically visible information pertain while an attraction on spiritual ideals that are unquantifiable relates to idealism.

Is not idealism relevant nowadays? Based on prof. Berend-Jan Mulder, the elite continues to be informed in its edition of thinking, specifically this one needs to follow his/her very own period, rejecting hence in the time unlikely rationalizing of stubborn and culture conservatism. Kees Schuyt described in his programs like a country of commercialists, however, based on him, examining the proportion of the people hectic with industrial actions, the situation for this being accurate the Dutch folks observe themselves is significantly less than previously.

Some Ideas:

You want to enjoy, what we might infer in the files examined, that it's facets which created the current political unrest Within The Netherlands or the determining element.

We believe about the designs offered within the about the following site.

1st hypothesis: a=Pim Fortuyn, b=present unrest, c=economical problems (i.e. Fortuyn obvious cause, economy actual cause);

2nd hypothesis: a=economy, b=unrest, c=Fortuyn (i.e. economy obvious cause, Fortuyn actual cause);

3rd hypothesis: a=911, b=unrest, c=economy (911 obvious cause, economy actual cause);

4th hypothesis: a=economical problems, b=unrest, c=911 (911 actual cause, economy obvious cause);

5th hypothesis: d=Fortuyn+911, e=economy, f=unrest (both ideological causes and substance causes, within their overlapping, they created the current scenario).

Operationalization of the Ideas

To be able to operationalize the ideas, we created three Boolean factors: being whether wording of a person or perhaps a record addressing an organization; possibly before or after Pim Fortuyn; and possibly before or after Sept 11th.

The previous rule of large therapy “Senatus bestia, senatori boni viri” (The Senate is just an animal, while senators are great guys) claims that the concept addressing an organization ought to be harder (in its text) compared to phrase of a person. In much this rule is empirically confirmed we will have below.

Subsequently, to be able to produce another two Boolean factors, an area was included by us using every text's day. Then the artificial class was calculated by us . Subsequently, we observed you will find just four groups, therefore we recoded for you will find just four ideals of the artificial class: syn2=1 for syn1=4 syn2=3 for.

Then we shall look for the ideas 1-4 if one cause appears significantly notable compared to additional, to ensure that if totally cancels the other one (this being hence an obvious trigger). If this doesn't maintain, speculation 5 could be confirmed, so long as it's enough related and backed by texts therein.


Within the Assertion of 1998 (only doc for syn2=1 worried about the aliens), the tone of talk is moderate and mild, providing convenience towards the aliens, and seeking in the same time for you to manage these bad oranges which difficulty the general public picture of the aliens:

Op een terreinen eist de maatschappelijke positie van etnische groepen echter onze aandacht op werkloosheid is hardnekkig hoog en de vorderingen in het soms achter that is blijven. Bij de bestrijding van de hoge zullen de p organisaties van werkgevers en werknemers en p minderhedenorganisaties nauw moeten samenwerken.

Zal extra worden voor het jeugdbeleid en voor inburgeringsmaatregelen. Steden zullen beter in worden gesteld om de die te verbeteren that is achterblijven.

Maar er ook probleemjongeren, onder autochtonen that is zowel als onder allochtonen. Een beperkt deel van de allochtone jongeren in ons property is verantwoordelijk voor een relatief hoog aandeel in jeugdcriminaliteit that is p. Ook hierop is het wat niet mag zal worden toegestaan.

We observe that actually since that time, the political discussion approved towards the phrases “wijken” and “buurten” various party ideals, specifically this one of what “secretly” pertains to habitats dominated from the Dutch people and also the additional term put on the habitats dominated by aliens, as B.J.Mulder once observed.

We observe that for both ideals syn2=2 and syn2=3, there's small mention of the the shared perspective upon the immigrants; the only real text item that appears to tackle this problem is in King's Talk towards the Parliament of 2001:

Eerder dit jaar is in werking getreden nieuwe vreemdelingenwet. Door de verkrijgen eerder dan voorheen duidelijkheid over vraag of zij tot ons property kunnen worden toegelaten. Minderjarige asielzoekers zullen sneller weten of hun verblijf. Vreemdelingen die hier niet mogen blijven, zullen ons land.

This pathways factors of creating the destiny of the immigrants better for themselves towards a will. Additionally, it demonstrates a hardening of center towards those people who are declined, making them to depart, which we all know in the press that it had been undue to the issues of numerous bleeding hearts.

Aliens' difficult is just a concept of Fortuyn. Therefore, small interest was handed in those days to him. This really is after Sept 11th and before Fortuyn. After his demise, we discover a good amount of reasons which make reference to the aliens; the vocabulary turned severe, cruel:

Vertrouwen … geen that are geschokt antwoord op de moeizame. (Report 2002)

Meedoen slaat zeker ook op immigranten in ons property. Iemand die blijvend wil en magazine vestigen in ons property, kan zich als toeschouwer in maatschappij opstellen. Doet hij niet alleen zichzelf tekort, maar ook zijn kinderen en de hele samenleving waarin hij leeft. Het kabinet stelt daarom scherpere eisen bij inburgering. P eigen verantwoordelijkheid van daarbij voorop that is immigrant. Wie deel wil uitmaken van onze maatschappij moet daar ook zelf iets voor doen. En magazine op die foundation ook verwachten dat onze. Leven in Nederland is niet. (Report 2003).

But about the economy, was this just because of Fortuyn, or, less folks got accepted to talk about inside it since the dessert got less?

For syn2=1 we've:

De financiële uitgangssituatie van waaruit dit kabinet begin is gunstiger dan vier jaar geleden that is veel. (Report 1998).

Na een aantal opeenvolgende jaren met een gunstige internationale conjunctuur magazine de mogelijkheid van een periode met een wat minder voorspoedige groei niet worden uitgesloten. De ontwikkelingen in kunnen een negatieve uitstraling op groei in p relaxation van de. Het begrotingsbeleid is opnieuw gebaseerd op behoedzame aannames voor wat betreft de te verwachten economische. De kans op wordt zo that is tegenvallers verkleind. (Ibidem).

For syn2=2 there's a serious problem for that state-of state funds:

Ondanks een tragere groei van ons inkomen zal volgend jaar ofwel ruim 3,5 miljard dollar, additional beschikbaar komen voor kwaliteitsverbetering in de gezondheidszorg. Het werken in publieke sector aantrekkelijker gemaakt that is wordt. Het begrotingsoverschot zal in 2002 naar binnenlands product bedragen. (Throne Speech 2001).

There have been no issues about economy. Perhaps Holiday lowering expenses and isn't the full time to talk about cash. For syn2=4, the next severe steps are now being sophisticated:

We moeten staatsschuld in één generatie aflossen. Dat is de course naar een. (Report 2002).

Apparent pessimism is there:

Maar ons property dreigt uit Europese kopgroep te vallen. Onze concurrentiepositie is afgelopen jaren. P arbeidskosten zijn te sterk gestegen. P inflatie is te hoog. P winstgevendheid en de investeringen van. Oudere werknemers en laaggeschoolden, p arbeidsparticipatie van vrouwen is te laag. Het begrotingsoverschot blijkt helaas nog duurzaam. Het besef dat het is nog steeds doorgedrongen. Hoge aandeelkoersen, een dure buck, forse stijging van huizenprijzen en meevallers overheidsinkomsten hebben het zicht op de. Signalen staan op het sluit daar niet de ogen voor. (Ibidem).

De Nederlandse is in een cruciale fase. Im is een risico dat we meer en meer komen te staan that is achterstand. Er zijn kansen om weg naar herstel in te slaan. Ten opzichte van de recessie van start jaren 'eighty zijn de economische fundamenten en de overheidsfinanciën beter. Maar de toekomst heeft ook duidelijk risicois john destijds. (Report 2003).

Therefore, having a damage of economy, which became conscious in-public discussion, the time of Fortuynis demise coincided according towards the syn2. Therefore we can not state that one of these simple two causes cancels out another one. 2 and theory 1 are hence declined not as true.

Same evaluation of the economy retains for that assessment with occasions of Sept 11th as reason for revolutionary change in politics. For syn2=1, there's, clearly, no mention of the September to occasions. But, there's an issue for military assistance with Usa, on the basis of the following factors:

Voor ons veiligheidsbeleid zijn een effectieve NAVO en een sterke group onontbeerlijk that is transatlantische. De Nederlandse met inzet van geoefend en van moderne middelen een hoogwaardige bijdrage aan vredesoperaties en personeel. Daarnaast verleent de humanitaire hulp en steun gegeven aan wederopbouw that is wordt. Voor de inzet van allen die bestaat grote waardering, daaraan bijdragen. (Report 1998).

For syn2=2 we've:

P afschuwelijke week geleden in de Verenigde Staten hebben vele duizenden onschuldige mensen van het leven beroofd. (Throne Speech 2001).

Tegen de menselijkheid doen ons beseffen hoe kwetsbaar ons aller bestaan is. Zij sterken ons in de iedere vorm van terrorisme met with moet worden bestreden. (Ibidem).

Internationale samenwerking that is nauwe is noodzakelijker dan ooit om fundamentele waarden van en te verdedigen. (Ibidem).

For syn2=3 we've a defensive method of placing the debate, producing attract the fundamental Religious ideals of love and empathy, particular towards the Holiday, however a powerful concept is created underneath the safety of those ideals (Jesus and also the Caesar were never friends with one another, claims the Bible):

Het menselijk bestaan is kwetsbaar. … Niettemin heeft de geschiedenis geleerd dat geen enkele gevrijwaard is tegen misbruik en verkondiging. Haat aanwakkeren en voeden, wanneer ideologieën en aanzetten tot onverdraagzaamheid, houdt op. (Christmas Speech 2001).

Fanate haat en de vernietigende kracht van het kwaad troffen de westerse dit jaar met een schok die gevoelens van geborgenheid aantast in welbehagen en diep ingrijpt. Het menselijk bestaan is intens kwetsbaar en de samenleving broos, waar onze moderne maatschappij that was juist met al zijn luxe en zekerheden een gevoel van onaantastbaarheid gebracht. (Ibidem).

For syn2=4 we've:

Zeker zijn van lijf en leden ze, politici moeten als iedere hamburger trouwens, zoals slachtoffer worden van, Pim Fortuyn. Het is als politici moeten onderduiken that is onacceptabel. (Report 2002).

Een kabinet dat uit een. Hebben aan een onderstroom van that is uiting onvrede, van onbehagen en van geschokt vertrouwen. Onvrede over een politiek die de problemen waar burgers dagelijks mee te maken hebben te vaak onbenoemd zoals overlast en onveiligheid. (Ibidem).

Mede met het oog op de bestrijding van terrorisme zullen voorstellen worden gedaan voor een verdergaande Europese samenwerking op het gebied van buitenlands en veiligheidsbeleid. Gaat daarbij uit naar het continueren van de hechte relatie met with de Verenigde Staten. (Throne Speech 2003).

Groeperingen trachten and daden onschuldige burgers en kinderen het slachtoffer worden achieved, over de te ondergraven that was samenlevingen. Ook Nederland is gevrijwaard that is niet van deze dreigingen. Om onze rechtsstaat en pluriforme samenleving te beschermen tegen terreur, heeft de regering aangekondigd op korte termijn ingrijpende maatregelen te treffen. De bestrijding van terrorisme de mogelijkheid om maatregelen te nemen, zal worden versterkt door een betere organisatie en door bepaalde opsporingsbevoegdheden te verruimen. Zal, mede met with het oog op voorlichting that is sufficient, een waarschuwings- in werking worden gesteld. (Throne Speech 2004).

The vary from the great motives of worldwide solidarity, under Kokis management, towards the reputation the new case seemed in the combined worries, which functional steps are mounted on this explanation of details, it represents the ability of the Sept 11th concept within the Dutch politics.

Therefore, 4 and the ideas 3 are declined. There's left the speculation number. 5, that will be enough backed from the estimates above, and atleast it's provable that for that Dutch decision-makers both substance concept and also the ideological concept are related, therefore no phrase of this type of duality could be refuse as minor in detailing the current evolutions:

Voor een duidelijk herkenbaar Europees en profiel is realistische, een pragmatische, aanpak nodig that is slagvaardige en ook. Idealistisch als het om onze beginselen en doelstellingen. Als het gaat om het bewaken van de Nederlandse that is pragmatisch positie en belangen. Realistisch als het gaat om haalbaarheid en het zetten van stappen that is cement. Als het gaat om het speed waarin en p overtuigingskracht waarmee wij opereren. Onze inspanningen in internationale organisaties en de samenwerking met with de Europese partners zijn onlosmakelijk verbonden met with bilaterale betrekkingen. Wij zullen doorgaan met with versteviging daarvan. (Report 1998).

We realized once the suggestions therein didn't straight help these estimates that these styles didn't include suggestions in complete contradiction above, the suggestions weren't questioning them both. These files verify the concept that each words are milder than communications from the team: the vocabulary was significantly milder once the King had independence over her very own talk, despite of severe motives. An alternate description is the fact that harshness doesn't squeeze into the Christmas' image.

The concept of Sept 11th is a lot more touching and developed compared to concept of LPF and Fortuyn. To be able to show this we wanted for that subsequent search filter: “fortu”OR “lpf”. There's appallingly small mention of the Fortuyn. For that search filter “leefb” (as-is “leefbaar” and “leefbaarheid”, etc.) you will find four short recommendations (filters are utilized without quotes). This demonstrates of creating things appear little a means.

But, using the reputation as details of individual irrationality and of individual inequality, within the Assertion of 2002 (of the government including LPF), several clichés destination been damaged, and political correctness is confirmed to be true-to the reality and true-to the required answer, in the place of staying an exaggeration of governmental politeness according to minor interest organizations:

Nog daargelaten dat mensen vaak wensen hebben. … Niet dogmatisch van uniformiteit. Verscheidenheid in aanpak en oplossingen zijn niet langer taboe.

On scientific-logical reasons it's challenging to determine which of both views operates the very best for making sense of their state of reality, for every of these has the capacity to immunize itself against confirmation, by declaring the causality in another of the ideas 1-4 is definitely obvious causality. On reasons of theoretical beauty and explanative completeness (view Wallace and Woolf), nevertheless, it retains what we've demonstrated above: no element therein is powerful enough to create us totally disregard the additional element as related.

Idealistic Analysis

In short, “materialism” claims that as a result of decreasing of common survival, to be able to deal with the possible lack of fulfillment which benefits from affordable sick states need to consider severe steps. “Idealism” claims that due to the neocons in California, it happens what it occurs.

We might reckon that both views are thus accurate, therefore the dualism called above is confirmed. All September 11th, Pim Fortuyn and the economic stagnation was essential to create what goes on today within the Netherlands.

An unique situation of the propagandistic price continues to be examined by Alvin Gouldner, who desired to create social researchers conscious of why they decide for this or that kind of concept (type of pre existing theoretical flavor). We might reckon that this applies that the quantity of training of the person getting such feedback can also be related in this problem, and mutatis mutandi. This really is obviously a topic for further study.

Findings and Speculations

Messages stay an essential section of policymaking. They're designed to affect the conduct of the populace, telling it of modifications such policy, and by persuading it to simply accept the policy. E.g., most, that will be bereft of the degree, is because of failure of creating sense of chat, by its character not able to consult the development of regulation, so that it exhibits small curiosity about law's texts. Way of just about established governmental utterances, those that are very popular within the press knowledgeable of main modifications within the regulation it. Obviously, there's an alternate signal of info, specifically when individuals who attempt to resolve an issue they've (e.g., increasing the profits they get from interpersonal aid) fulfill their friends and trade what worked and what didn't work-in a particular scenario. We reckon that this really is signal of data that will be favored from the lower courses and from the cultural minorities, who're mainly not able to follow established discussion that is extremely literate. However it can also be, apparently, the aged kids' network's preferred signal.

The establishment of the Master (as within the Dutch Structure), it's an establishment having a custom which dates back in occasions whereby small quantitative measurements were being done, and political thinking was mainly intuitive-qualitative. This, obviously, using the Chaldeans within the antiquity's exclusion, to do particular clever statistical measurements to be able to help the policymaking of some powers who have been stated. And sophisticated numerical understanding, which it's a question that it existed is proven by some marvels of this era.

We genuinely believe that the general public associations (study: propaganda) professionals of the government when composing Throne Messages required such custom into consideration. (Propaganda merely means: increasing assistance and/ or for this type of standpoint and producing anything known. It's an idea that we employ bereft of factors of ethical value, as just a governmental method among a number of other resources a government has at its order.)

To people who genuinely believe that propaganda is solely laying, we might reply that informative descriptions' volume is not significantly lesser than the amount of words that are hypocritical. But, it would appear that such occasions individuals spend more focus on being robbed (for this reason we settled so much focus on the hypocrisy and archaic guarantees and objectives inside Dutch propaganda) than for them being informed facts, and so the concern for not switching propaganda owned by statesmanship right into a statesmythomanship is just a genuine problem, observed there are usually cynics who appreciate destroying common impression, while they're not able to place anything better within the location (within the combined psychological) therefore emptied. Abroad, the factors will vary, and all of the reality warm enthusiasm of his like and the Michael Moore has the capacity to do little from totally distorting all feeling of truth in US dialogue to avoid the Straussian mythmaking machine. The dissertation of Le Bon the improvement component is for that people not the reality, the illusions, however the lies, it's below confirmed. You could just warn either part: possibly alethophobic or alethophile extremism, they both harm culture.

This notion describes “idealistic” reasons in current Queen'sSpeeches' variety. Another concept was indicated above, primarily the bulk to comprehend technology as such's mess. We can not all be training in College, some need to create clear about the roads. You might suggest the concept of choosing individuals based on competence be truly adopted, in the place of being officially spread due to the worries you have while doing activities her express rational proficiency. For, based on B.J. Mulder, “the best-man within the place” that is greatest is just a hypocritical fantasy designed to legitimize the ability elite.

It's a naïve picture that the government has duty reductions, punishments modifications of such and regulation, to be able to execute politics. The ability of marketing shouldn't be underestimated. Phrases have energy (think about Marx's Money).

Therefore, messages may stay a means of politics that is doing in policymaking's specific meaning, plus they are an inseparable element of it. Atleast they're ready to complete anything although messages can't do everything in issues of state plan, plus they CAn't be overlooked therein. Talk traditions are, in Durkheimis meaning, an alternative and/or complement for that currently rotting spiritual involvement, and, while they CAn't change the “real thing” (religious zeal), they're nevertheless capable to help team unity and share with some a meaning in a disappointed world, whereby the “gods” have flown, or atleast people are no further able to make contact with and follow them.

This type of nonviolent supply of energy has hence particular usefulness also it matches towards the picture the American individuals have of civil conduct, and atleast it's required in sustaining the connection between your populace and also the government, and we reckon that bereft of such conversation, populace might alienate itself in the governmental reasons of the government, leading to insufficient handle, anarchy, with worst effects. Therefore, this evidently totally banal, archaic and ritualistic trend is very important in dealing with execute a politics.

In your final comment, Malinowskiis functionalism stated that the cultural trend is really because folks believe it is not organic. Based on Parsons' functionalism, it exists since it is practical. And Merton requires: could it be structural or practical? Its capabilities, are they hidden or express? And: is not it organic ?

In a culture which works together with icons, it's naïve to consider since they're considered to function the symbols exist. They use a concealed energy, which frequently escapes the human beings' understanding. Evaluating between Malinowski and Parsons is just a complex theoretical dialogue, anyhow, we might place the cultures who criticized the ability of phrases, the ability suggestions, possibly by repressing freedom of speech, or by an overindulgence according towards the pathology of free speech, they corroded and vanished.

We observe that even though class materialism was underrepresented, it can't skip therein. West isn't as materialistic as strict fundamentalists everywhere (including US) declare that it's. It merely has its laymenis idealism and its particular laymenis transcendence (like a dialogue is freely happening in French Masonic circles and around these groups).

Prof. Schuyt said that essential that what's being said, it's what's not being said. This really is a typical example of anti-logocentrism. The University's goal would be to place purchase in to facts' accessible pile, to topic them underneath the images.

Materialism signifies to be able to change the interest from the affordable interests of the ability elite that, due to the decreasing of common survival, difficult steps are essential. Idealism claims that liberal democracy's real disaster has factors, mainly the disenchantment of the American people according for their own program. Materialism claims that the assault about the welfare-state of Fortuyn had substance factors, or, atleast, it displayed particular groups' substance pursuits. Idealism claims that the content conditions' decline may be the consequence of social decay, from slipping in to the lure of sweet hedonism and losing the Calvinistic effort.

For that materialistic perspective, there's accessible a reasonably effective (in the logical perspective) formalism, specifically through calculating financial and para-financial moves, there follow “hard” findings upon the desirability and capability of creating accurate some reasons of plan.

In regard that was such, the viewpoint is empirically operationalized we might declare it's formalized. But, their state of details demonstrates the metaphysical-theological thinking is again current, observed that it today (factually) has control around the world program. So in its capability of people that are effective, it's better than the bureaucratic rationality of Weber.

On the complex method (method), the aforementioned called anti-logocentrism has terminated the subsistence problems of rationalized politics. Therefore, we're seeing signs that are incipient the considering the Enlightenment is just starting to not become adequate to cultural reality. The task of the Enlightenment is obsolete as Allan Bloom claims, as well as the Enlightenment was enforced from by the governmental program. In the viewpoint of affecting conduct that is large, rationality remains an intelligent oddity, most likely a wish of some thinkers that are unlikely.

We might in most guarantee acknowledge the elite determined that it's again as soon as to check out the times, and also the elite created a variety among politicians, choosing people who were organized for these times. This describes why the phrases that have been incorrect five years back, they're currently established plan: not since politicians are evil-minded and mean, but since the new occasions don't permit the extension of welfare state that is modern.


Bourdieu, P., The Substance of Neoliberalism,;

Impact, L., [Journey of Study, Schools], School of Amsterdam, 2003;

De Swaan, A., [Sociological Ideas 1A, Visitor University], School of Amsterdam, 2003;

Droogleever-Fortuijn, E., [Recommendations for Duties and Connected Files], Blackboard of College of Amsterdam, 2004-2005;

Le Bon, G., The Group,;

Le Bon, G., The Therapy of Innovation,;

Mulder, B.J., [Schools], Educative School Amsterdam, 2002-2003;

Rutten, M., Azië van binnen en van buiten, Oration at College of Amsterdam, July 6th, 2003;

Schuyt, C.J.M., [Sociology of Plan, Schools], School of Amsterdam, 2004;

Touret, D., Une psychologie sociale réaliste, ;

Van Heerikhuizen, B., [Sociological Ideas, Schools], School of Amsterdam, 2004;

R.A., Wallace, Woolf, A. Sociological Theory. Growing the Traditional History. Fifth edition. Upper Saddle River, Prentice Hall, 1980-1999.

Annex: Doc System

Teams that are text

King's individual talk

Kerst 2001

Government conditions

Regeringsverklaring 1998

Regeringsverklaring 2002

Regeringsverklaring 2003

Throne messages

Troonrede 1999

Troonrede 2000

Troonrede 2001

Troonrede 2002

Troonrede 2003

Troonrede 2004



Government declarationsRegeringsverklaring 1998

Throne speechesTroonrede 1999

Throne speechesTroonrede 2000


Throne speechesTroonrede 2001


Queen's individual speechKerst 2001


Authorities declarationsRegeringsverklaring 2002

Government declarationsRegeringsverklaring 2003

Throne speechesTroonrede 2002

Throne speechesTroonrede 2003

Throne speechesTroonrede 2004

Annex: Initial Code Program

The very first signal program may be the following:

Code Program



Informative explanations

hypocritical pretensions


qualitative observations

Prices (or charm thereupon)




Activity of quantitative evaluation


Administration of public problems

quantitative ecology

Requirement for powerful plan


Spoken bonuses and admonitions

Annex: Ultimate Rule Program

The created signal program may be the following:

Code Program


Environmental observations

Informative explanations

Individual irrationality

Individual inequality

hypocritical pretensions



qualitative observations

political science


the Dutch particular

Beliefs and emotions



West and American





Marketplace philosophy


Logical behaviour




Pim Fortuyn

Requirement for powerful plan





State-of legislation


Activity of quantitative evaluation


Administration of public problems

quantitative ecology




Spoken bonuses


Annex: Signal Matrix


King's individual speechKerst 2001

Government declarationsRegeringsverklaring 1998

Government declarationsRegeringsverklaring 2002

Government declarationsRegeringsverklaring 2003

Throne speechesTroonrede 1999

Throne speechesTroonrede 2000

Throne speechesTroonrede 2001

Throne speechesTroonrede 2002

Throne speechesTroonrede 2003

Throne speechesTroonrede 2004

idealisticvalues and feelingsdemocraticindividualistic

0 2 4 0 0 2 0 2 1 2

idealisticvalues and feelingsdemocraticdecentralization

0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1


0 9 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 2

dualisticecological observations

0 3 0 0 2 1 0 1 1 0

informative explanations

4 5 8 9 27 16 9 0 1 0

informative descriptionshuman inequality

0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

informative descriptionshuman irrationality

0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

hypocritical pretensions

1 4 3 3 7 2 4 0 0 1

hypocritical pretensionsantiquated

0 1 1 2 1 1 1 0 0 0


0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

idealisticqualitative observations

0 0 4 2 2 2 2 3 3 2

idealisticqualitative insightspolitical technology

0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0

idealisticqualitative insightsecology

0 0 0 0 1 1 3 0 0 0

idealisticqualitative insightsthe Dutch particular

0 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0

idealisticvalues and emotions

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

idealisticvalues and feelingsaliens

0 5 2 1 0 0 1 0 1 0

idealisticvalues and feelingscivilization

3 1 3 0 2 2 1 2 0 1

idealisticvalues and feelingscivilizationWest and American

1 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 0 0

idealisticvalues and feelingsdemocratic

2 6 9 2 3 2 0 1 3 2

idealisticvalues and feelingsglobalization

0 11 3 3 5 6 7 3 4 4

idealisticvalues and feelingsmarket philosophy

0 8 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 0

idealisticvalues and feelingsnational

0 3 1 0 0 2 2 2 1 3

idealisticvalues and feelingsrational conduct

1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

idealisticvalues and feelingsreligious

4 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 2

idealisticvalues and feelingssecurity

2 8 5 2 2 4 7 7 1 5

idealisticvalues and feelingssecurity911

1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0

idealisticvalues and feelingssecurityPim Fortuyn

0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

idealisticvalues and feelingssecurityneed for powerful plan

0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0

idealisticvalues and feelingssolidarity

0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0

idealisticvalues and feelingssolidarityinternational

0 2 0 1 2 0 1 0 0 1

idealisticvalues and feelingssolidaritynational

2 5 3 6 4 2 1 1 2 3

idealisticvalues and feelingssolidaritynationalredistribution

0 4 3 1 0 2 3 0 4 2

idealisticvalues and feelingsstate of regulation

2 5 5 2 4 3 2 3 3 1


0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

materialisticsynthesis of quantitative evaluation

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2

materialisticsynthesis of quantitative analysiseconomy

0 4 4 3 1 1 2 5 8 7

materialisticsynthesis of quantitative analysismanagement of public problems

0 5 4 3 0 0 3 0 2 0

materialisticsynthesis of quantitative analysisquantitative ecology

0 4 2 0 2 1 2 1 0 1


0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1


0 2 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0


0 10 12 10 14 11 14 2 5 1

spoken bonuses

0 2 4 2 1 1 1 1 0 0

spoken incentivesadmonitions

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Annex: Memo Program

Code Memos

Into texts were coded this annex is supposed to provide further depth. The argumentation is intended how this occurred, because, for instance of providing a heavy concept, we couldn't study at length every state of all stances coded as hypocritical's scientific wrongness. This provides a typical example of technique that is idealistic.

Memo 6

Code hypocritical pretensions

Writer tg

Creation Time 01/16/2005

1. From Wallace and Woolf, p.173: Habermas claims: the officially democratic program wishes and enables no real involvement, simply because they might become conscious that expenses are combined (all need to subscribe to common production) and earnings are personal (not many benefit from the accurate advantages of such combined production). Therefore, Paretois 20-80 regulation, which Habermas confirms that it's empirically accurate is essentially restated by Habermas. In this way, Paretois 20-80 isn't restricted to the elitist discussion of the best side, however it can also be a related device for that review of the (today aged) New Left.

2. Little claims have choice. They didn't produce this type of historic development, however for that option is global isolation they needed to join evolution in insufficient a much better option. It's unfortunate that there's people who're not to get a governmental place, and no middle approach, they're instantly measured to be against it. I believe there's no official evidence that globalization brings peace that is global. There's merely an attract some confidence collected within the fifty years, and also the wish the truth that is cultural wont oppose this imagine unity.

3. Within an economical condition-of-details that will be seen as a intense concurrence, it's an impression to consider that individuals, since they're informed thus through stereo and tv may welcome cooperation and supportive conduct in the place of the extremely worrying concurrence that they have previously internalized, which is in their every day life.

4. One can't remove all unemployment, for you will find individuals who begin to see the socialaid like a type of reliable revenue (cf. Wallace and Woolf, p.…) that allows them to follow their personal projects in comparable independence from interpersonal-affordable duties.

5. That UWV is customer, although I've noticed a lot of things in my own existence -friendly beats all of them! Amusing.

6. A parliamentary reported that before all ultra modern medical improvements, a is according as to the they would be by disease reach 40-45's age. Therefore, medical improvements aren't always for the patients' great. Euthanasia definitely stops them from obtaining spirit answer; this is actually the meaning of the assault on voluntary closing one existence of St.Paul. Life isn't a responsibility, although a benefit. It's to not be existed just as it sits missing serious discomfort, or awesome, pleased. It's a dreadful responsibility which God added aside from his/her faith her religious views, on everybody.

7. Inside health care, it's the medical program that will be main, not the individual. This really is demonstrated from the determining cultural ideals in lighting of the medical-science (view Wallace and Woolfis instance for Parsonis major model).

8. “We reside quietly with each other” doesn't match cultural reality. Notice Theo van Gogh and Pim Fortuyn.

9. “The Pound strengthens Europe economically”, it's not quickly objectionable (falsifiable). But, that it strengthens it is hardly well looking for some evidence. This independence of money and product cultural privileges the many. There's proof that is little the Western neighborhood facilitates the formation of a local welfare state. Today, the welfare-state is a lot under risk, just about everywhere, which is nearly wishful thinking to picture that it'd be considered a genuine goal of the EU. Some comforting and helpless affirmations might be formalized in Western agreements, however the social treatment element sits, factually, among the many overlooked by present policymaking. The evaluation of along day of Marx is very current, and Europe can't afford to motion in prejudice of innovations offshore.

10. Projects of work with immigrants is just a possibly newsworthy although not a related trend, because of its (i) tiny scale according to socially desirable placement (appealing, based on the Dutch people) (ii) when large-scale, this means unwanted cultural jobs, i.e. jobs-which embarrass the social and rational worth of these who execute such careers (e.g. Kurdish immigrants. Diploma or more educational diploma who'd no option but producing clear for those who have intellects significantly inferior for their own).

11. Throwing a vote is pretended as extremely essential, however it comes with an excessively low-importance, observed in pressing several switches the internal existence of a person gets indicated, with imagination and individual involvement. It's more a pretense of involvement (a confidence routine, based on Alvin Toffler's Third-Wave), than the usual actual involvement of the person in-public issues.

12. Globalization provides more wealth to merely an area of the globe. Other areas get conflicts, famines, exploitation of natural assets, (factually) slave work, gender vacation, child neglect, etc.

13. Cultural companions were humiliated disbanded from the government.

14. The tradition of poverty is among the greatest issues this Planet understood although no body really wants to be bad. Survival of the globe for several people? God forbid! It'd imply causeing the world inhabitable period. You have to prevent thinking by what is good for a person of the people. One realize there might be no chat of sustainable development and should get actual. For the most part, we might speak for several nations of the World, of lasting underdevelopment, provided there's nevertheless anything lasting with this world. Accident the desires of business and Fund needs to state its term! All the spiritual judgment it had should be born again by usage. For we might no further talk of good things we're not referring to good things. We might just speak of what's not unnecessary.

Its record publications may be oneday written in by an alien world visiting Planet: beings who even attempted to create their uncomfortable desires accurate, and held thinking all of the day-long inhabited the World. That could not be born by their world, just why they're an specie which is. I would want it's science-fiction!

15. Provide an opportunity to improvement? When reading it no, no, Malthus is submiting his plot!

16. Launch of the Pound cash was a very sour dessert for several customers for those of earnings, specifically within the Netherlands. Because of some ex-ante info discrepancy between sellers and customers, there occurred an informative nation wide cartel development of the sellers, who changed gulden's hallmark using the indication of Pound, normally maintaining the exact same ciphers due to their costs. Perhaps this seems negative, however this cynicism is broadly discussed from the Dutch populace, who realized that what “us all” within the emblem for that launch of the Pound, these phrases didn't affect the entire of the Dutch people, but simply to those that make money from their usage, hence from their function. Another evidence that political confidence is just of creating sense of cultural reality a malformation.

If we begin with the belief that individuals are logical, then we ought to place in necessary psychological treatment the next (i) everybody who consents towards the items of a solitary marketing place (ii) everybody that allows herself/herself persuaded from the messages of the politicians.

It's scientific proof that, everywhere and typically, the professional contract's little letters totally oppose its characters that are large. Lodewijk Brunt, in his program “Adventure of research”, described his interest of counting just how many mistakes of logic exist in a public talk or public doc, and he explained when this type of talk or document has significantly less than 30 or 40 mistakes of reasoning, then it's excellent in its large thinking quality, since it is quite unusual that politicians and bureaucrats manage to such reasonable precision. We observe from (ii) that, if everyone was logical and seeking their very own pursuits, they'd not permit themselves being persuaded from the political messages, so they really might become insubordinate and mayhem might result. Logical creatures (as within the homo oeconomicus type) are consequently ungovernable. Cheers receive towards the Master, Who didn't permit intelligence that was much towards the several!

17. The dialogue concerning the atmosphere ignores what appears to me a particular reality: that, in our social, financial and governmental program of the West along with other areas of the planet, the difficult of environmental damage sits with no legitimate (efficient) solution. I believe not less about obtaining a picture of obligation and ecological problem has been completed than it's being completed to avoid the environmental decay, by itself. It's more of the battle of various ways of paying lip service, possibly against or for plan that is inexperienced, and their competitors as well as vegetables likewise appear to dismiss that at the moment there is no actual answer that will be capable to avoid an international environmental catastrophe. Someone stated on a web checklist, that, if we weren't ourselves concerned what people do for this planet might appear exceptionally amusing, e.g. To an alien world who'd visit with this world and might observe what we're performing to ourselves and also to it.

18. In the standpoint of the propagandist, refraining from allowing the people drain into hopelessness is just a seated and genuine problem, for toughest will be anticipated when the people become eager. Consequently, the talk needs to be mindful to not split their confidence that is short, to regard the illusions they've, so as to not change everything right into a mayhem. But, so far as we're worried, as researchers, we've to become conscious that confidence is home in short illusions, that the truth is certainly not soothing, actually on the other hand, the truth is intense and cruel, which it's reactive to silly behaviour (i.e. Conduct governed by illusions). Technology is not being unaware of truth. A perspective of fear develops for doom's researcher, the terrible perspective of truth,. E.g., within the Religious thinking, Daniel section 2 postulates social and environmental pessimism, and also the Thought attempted to alert those accountable that, in the unacceptable start of individual medical business (what Heidegger titles Gestell), just toughest will be anticipated, like a normal result. Understanding has its laws when laws are ignored by us. And, understanding has results that are actual. Human-nature being a continuing, it's no surprise that catastrophe might be expected with precision by these of this unacceptable and conscious of the truth of human-nature start. The evidence of the expertness of these who published the Sacred Scriptures, it's within the proven fact that several uncomfortable people of the antiquity might produce suggestions which generate vast amounts of people, while us, in most our satisfaction of understanding anything concerning the individuals (as folks so that as collectives), we're unable to create. We've to recuperate the data that such authors had if you want to remain any opportunity.

19. In large therapy, there's confirmed empirically that people are alethophobic. In this way, technology, understanding, reality, are far more frequently than not thing of personal and combined dislike, consequently spending such lip-service that is uncomfortable towards the need for science isn't likely to support significantly. the recommended marketization of the larger education proves this dislike. All would be made by this -to-temporary interests master, and long-term and heavy technology fruitfulness would rot. Besides, based on Köbben, dislike that is such is endemic: democracy and capitalism don't benefit technology, however they have proven their contempt. For, when large affordable and governmental passions master, it's handy (for some) to damaged researchers, in the place of corrupting state authorities. E.g., is a rising problem according towards the threat of utilizing cell phones, however a minister has bashed the damaging TNO study thereupon. Of spending the statement for an incredible number of brain-damaged patients from today on he doesn't care. He just sees economic growth's temporary attention. It's not catastrophe, although development!

20. Based on prof. Schuyt, new guidelines are created by rules, rules that are less is impossible.

21. Due to individualization, their offspring forgotten seniors; they die in treatment of houses for that parent, funded specific businesses and from the condition.

22. Who gets wealthy from globalization, this will depend how most are the.

Memo 7

it is definitely an attraction about the civilizing part that the West bestowed upon itself, although I believe it's apparent that the attract being section of an extended historic development, it's no attract spiritual ideals as a result. The civilization, it's not false, it'd its source in Christianity, however now it's just a laymen's civilization. The road which US selected, within this regard, specifically go back to Religious principles, it varies from such historic development. Find out and one will need to delay even the conquering enthusiasm of Religious fundamentalists or which of both is tougher: the enthusiasm of the laymen. I believe the neoconservatives recognized that laymen's enthusiasm is significantly weaker compared to enthusiasm of fanaticism, plus they, being to be faced with an unfamiliar religious fundamentalism despaired, they attempted to counter attack it. It had been, obviously, an option between two evils: possibly being overcome or recovering the earliest styles of earth politics: faith and cure.

This can be a program an “idealistic” debate, to be able to persuade, an attract some imponderabilia, which, though we can not precisely evaluate, they're however apparent in an exceedingly long haul retrospective take on earth activities for this makes.

Memo 8

The “reserve army” (the unemployed) need to occur in most area, to be able to permit such field enough versatility according to these currently at the office, and supply an essential book of qualified staff. Milton Friedman underlined that unemployment is just a required security device which cares that economy keeps on the right track.

It's clinically really dubious that lowering the required education era has excellent results. An English psychiatrist demonstrated that really early training (day-care) escalates the personal tendency for chaotic conduct. Therefore, this well-meant measure is questionable from this kind of empirical reality.

I really hope that producing length decreasing occur; it generally does not refer to providing the people more power-over the company of the government, but that it relates to collecting intellect and the necessary technology to be able to grasp their conduct. Gustave Le Bon clinically demonstrates that people are anarchical prepared to ruin what's left of world; consequently handle is crucial, not really a wish of energy-insane political wannabees.

Figure out how to discover, for everyone, implies whichever training might they further follow and that politics views that merely permitting people with college training, it's insufficient. Individuals are triggered, plus some actually required, to internalize capabilities and information. Consequently, by producing the bond using the highlight on ideals and norms, we infer the government bestows upon their state an part, specifically the condition needs to teach the populace in to mind's required ideological frame. The generous concept of condition, in this way remains archaic, and thus does the idea of personal independence, according to public disturbance, and of independence to think whatsoever and also to express, aside from government intercession. Anyhow they're apparent within the will of the federal government, although maybe these ideas didn't become law texts. Consequently, re-education and propaganda are permitted to may play a role much more critical than they would be allowed by the generous concept of condition. This can be a reality, not price or an excellent. It's being performed at this time: their state is becoming ideological, in a method that is express. For all those followers in democracy, who're dissatisfied to listen to it, I've to express to get a simple allocation for that people to think issues at-will did never exist that this type of improvement was unavoidable. “If a country needs to become free and unaware, in a situation of world, it needs what never may be.” Thomas Jefferson and never was. Jefferson claims below: a civil country could not be blame or unaware. Thomas F. Forces “Welcome towards the omnipticon” overview of Independence estimates, within an Age Larry Ellison, Reclaiming Protection and Jeffrey Rosenis The Naked Group: “I donot comprehend [the experts]. Main databases currently exist. Solitude has already been gone.” And he provides: “By itself, the individual market has means, purpose and chance to occupy privacy in ways, and also to a diploma, that previously actually totalitarian authorities, with almost all their central energy, might just imagine. Yes, the risk authorities and that government can get this with this work (and, yes so after Sept 11) is genuine. But an easier stage is the fact that the tsunami of engineering, capitalism and democracy today moving over solitude won't simply be stopped.”

Memo 9

The Tribunal Within The Hague's morality is one sided: think about Bush, Putin and Blair? Did they not make offenses against mankind in Iraq? The entire Western world got humiliated from the violent and brutish conduct of the united states jail guards in several other such locations and Abu Ghraib. Military doctors' occupation appeared to reach the amount of most wretched individual conduct and cheapest, observe StevenH.Miles' research. Dr. Mengele could not be humble of doctors that are such as there!

Memo 10

First World War, next World War... Think about the large confidence concerning Nations' Category? If confidence indicates an improved notion of truth, of course if reality is reactive to measures resulting type its misperception, we (researchers) do not have to become positive concerning the potential! It'd not be also nasty that great results are produced by all great motives. Thinking that is traditional is not very unaware of reality that is such.

Memo 11

Economy has below two definitions: (i) an empirical research of the cultural structure which ascribes actual results to actual steps and/or digital facts; (ii) the principal philosophy that has to-do not with scientific technology, but by having an inappropriate generalization of some financial ideas, that will be offered in a kind of philosophy that will be being enforced without resistance (notice P.Bourdieuis research of the neo liberal paradise). Keynes' stating that many useful males in many cases are slaves of the useless economist, it's accurate here. Each economist supplied significantly more than an empirical evaluation; many of them likewise did (perhaps without having to be conscious of it) a governmental metaphysics, utilizing as building rocks of such program some financial regulations.

A Nobel Prize compensated two medical competitors of rationalism that was affordable. Therefore, if economy seems to not be rational, think about culture particularly, and think about human-nature generally? Individual rationality's dissertation demonstrates not empirically correct.

Memo 12

Class “national values” additionally includes both of these contradictory components:

(i) along history of threshold according to immigrants (e.g. Spinoza desired to suspend a poster using the phrases “Ultimi barbarorum” - with all Dutch threshold, it'd have now been deadly for him, had he not been secured in his space from the motel operator - anyhow, normally he was pretty well-tolerated).

(ii) the emotions to be a foreigner in a single's own nation (cf. mutatis mutandi MarioRutten's oration), to be disadvantaged according to immigrants, of perceiving a risk to national solidarity and national tradition, and outright hate words in values to different countries and countries. Be these emotions unreal, also they create results that are actual, based on W.I. Thomas' lemma.

Memo 13

Control of earnings that are leading did false; on the other hand, leading earnings increased significantly beyond before. Individuals eat more in downturn occasions, creates a dentist in City. Possibly since there is not a lot less marketing in these occasions, it being designed to promote the economy. If we take care of not completely messing this planet up the state should think about advertising's prohibition, because consumerism may destroy this planet, and advertising encourages consumerism, claims table-advertising.

Memo 14

Le Veau d'Or est vainqueur des dieux... (Gounod's Faust). Contains ICT and technological improvements, as philosophy, never as scientific observations.

Memo 15

Nationwide in addition to global solidarity.

“Also for newcomers”, the term “also” therein exhibits an amount which could quickly be overlooked, consequently we determine that beginners are noticed being an expendable class. This displays dislike of the federal government for class that is such.

If social exemption is behaviorally more related than interpersonal and affordable exemption (think about Ulianov and Schicklgruber, one a poet and also the additional an artist, who both turned dictators), if this then it uses that showing dislike to minor categories is just a factor one really gives, because of reactive personality of cultural truth of these marginalized groups. You can reckon that the homicide on Theo van Gogh was no structured terrorist action, however the anarchical result of an unpredictable person, who experienced after all of the same emotions that the people of his teams experience according to hated and being marginalized.

Just like Merton examined revolt to be able to allow the criminologists, and so the authorities, by having an detailed device for knowing legal conduct, exactly the same method, knowing the revolt which develops within the individual spirit, when confronted by organized social exemption of herself/herself and his/her peer-group, it allows the policy-maker to create greater guidelines, provided he or she is of enough intelligence.

Therefore, Crimson II's assertion launched and ideals and the part of the federal government according and also two styles within the political discussion: regard for that republican concept of regulation.

Memo 16

“One action behind, two actions ahead” - Stalin and Leninis policy of the Communist Party.

Correct conduct is just a difficulty, based on the Dutch populace, therefore split using the requirements of correctness and the government needs to follow the combined will. Besides, this view is definitely an instance of individual attitude, for people are permitted to split the guidelines of governmental politeness to be able to convey their frequently negative motives, just like if everyone converted into a sociologist within the last five decades (based on Schuyt, sociologists are cynics by their character).

Political correctness, in its basic meaning, means refraining from propagating mistakes and considering errors, and being true-to the reality. It's not the same as governmental politeness, i.e. being awesome towards nobody and everyone particularly, in each utterance a person makes according to additional governmental and interpersonal organizations.

Governmental politeness is just a luxurious item, e.g, for politics. Per Machiavelli, is just a company that allows for no luxury. Reality needs to be stated, even when the emotions of others affects. Individuals feel upset by laying elogies in the place of by unpleasant reality must mind that.

Nevertheless, if we analyze humankind's history, we discover what Hegel understood, i.e. that individuals mind nothing.

The written text beginning with kan de uitdagingen en niet alleen aan.” may be the turning-point within the dialogue between the republican concept of condition and also the generous concept of state, that are Habermas' ideas. We observe that within this passing, besides privileges and personal protections and possibilities, there seems the idea of the person accountability for that combined good-and wellness and also the idea of combined obligation. The authorities that were later stressed quite poignantly there are no protections without duties. This really is area of the milder communitarian ideology, in addition to area of the ideology. Although neoconservative philosophy challenges offshore interests and also the part of ideological turmoil (“good” vs. “evil” nations) which provides meaning towards the lifestyles of the people, the communitarian philosophy enables the neighborhood team to look for the destiny of the people owned by it. Therefore, neo-conservatism is macro- republican theory, while communitarianism is micro- republican theory that is governmental, view Habermas' difference between republican and generous legislation theory.

Memo 17

Cultural ecology is just a type of environmental thinking.

Memo 18

Signal informative descriptionshuman inequality

The federal government acknowledges that equality between humans' dissertation is nothing otherwise than dogma.

Memo 19

The next section is great to be cited within this framework:

Een duidelijk herkenbaar Europees en profiel is realistische, een pragmatische, aanpak nodig that is slagvaardige en ook. Idealistisch als het om onze beginselen en doelstellingen. Als het gaat om het bewaken van de Nederlandse that is pragmatisch positie en belangen. Realistisch als het gaat om haalbaarheid en het zetten van stappen that is cement. Als het gaat om het speed waarin en p overtuigingskracht waarmee wij opereren. Onze inspanningen in internationale organisaties en de samenwerking met with de Europese partners zijn onlosmakelijk verbonden met with bilaterale betrekkingen. Wij zullen doorgaan met de versteviging daarvan.”

Memo 20

Signal idealisticvalues and feelingssolidaritynational

Amazing, social communication was described for by this main location. Additionally, mentioning having large issues for this.

Means the resident who learns and also both people's reps /says the assertion. It's thus an ambiguous term.

Memo 21

Signal spoken incentivesadmonitions

You will find no admonitions as a result (actually). Nevertheless several utterances can be viewed as risks according to teams because the vocabulary utilized therein is difficult understood to be misbehaving; some were particularly addressed towards the aliens, and these were mainly coded under state and protection of regulation.

Concept Memo

Annex: Factors

Text Title

Quantity of Coded Segments







Regeringsverklaring 1998








Troonrede 1999








Troonrede 2000








Troonrede 2001








Kerst 2001








Regeringsverklaring 2002








Troonrede 2002








Regeringsverklaring 2003








Troonrede 2003








Troonrede 2004